
Happy November!
Have you ever had a TV show you’re embarrassed to admit you watch? I’m not sure I ever did…until now.
I was flipping channels one day when I came across a wedding ceremony – who doesn’t like seeing one of those? When the show went to commercial, I saw the title: “Married at First Sight”. At first I was curious, then I was stunned…maybe amazed would be more like it.
The Premise: After completing an application and doing a some tests and interviews, the experts pair up ten singles/five couples to be legally married to someone they never met. Here’s the crazy thing: they don’t find out that they are paired up until two weeks before the wedding. During those two weeks, instead of meeting and getting to know their new fiancé, they pick out their outfits, have parties, and pack for their honeymoon. The first time they actually meet their spouse-to-be is when they are at the altar, where they are introduced for the first time. Minutes later, they are legally married, have a reception and go on a honeymoon.
image
Once they return, the MAFS newlyweds agree to live together for sixty days – with cameras following them almost 24/7. After 2 months, they meet with the experts who paired them for “Decision Day”, which is a strange little meeting when the couples decide to either stay together or get a divorce.
The Reasoning: When I first watched MAFS, I laughed and thought “who, in their right mind, would agree to something like this?” However, as it turns out, the average number of applicants per season (each season is in a different city – Philadelphia included) is usually over 50,000. And, when asked why they do it, applicants say things like “I’ve been dating and haven’t found my person on my own, so I thought I’d let the experts find ‘my someone’.”
The Reality: The experts, Pastor Cal and Dr. Pepper, use psychological testing, interviews, social media, and discussion to match the couples. Sometimes the experts get it right – but, statistically, only about 15% of the couples stay married. One bride walked away only minutes after being introduced to her spouse-to-be.
The Takeaway: Until now, reality TV was never my thing. But I’ve been fascinated to see couples meet, court, marry and work out their relationship at warp speed. The marital mistakes become so clear, and frankly, they’re painful to watch. They are also very common to most couples. Here are two very common mistakes with the alternative that every couple can use to make their relationship better:
1 – Unspoken Expectations: The MAFS couples come into the marriage with their own set of expectations. They seldom share those with their new partner until problems come up, sometimes as early as the wedding day or the honeymoon. But, as in any relationship, they DO come up.
Sharing your expectations is important in any relationship – even if you’ve been together for years. Whether you’re getting married, taking a vacation, or planning a retirement, you and your partner have your own picture of what that event will look like. Say, for example, you plan a vacation to Mexico. Maybe you envision yourself sitting on the beach reading a book and sipping Margueritas. That’s good…until you find out that your partner sees the two of you hiking and exploring Aztec pyramids. Then you have a problem. If you had talked about it sooner, you would have saved yourselves some anger and hurt.
A few years ago, I did some coaching with a woman who looked for help when her spouse was retiring. In their pre-retirement years, her expectation was that they would be traveling far and wide, doing things she long dreamed about doing with him. However, she learned – unexpectedly – that his idea of retirement was spending time on his boat…in Florida. Not sharing their expectations led to a lot of hurt and anger. Once she realized the damage their unspoken expectations was doing to their very long marriage, she did something about it.
Unspoken Expectations can become a serious problem, and even lead to a divorce. Communicating what you expect, negotiating for what you want, and making spoken agreements are the keys to fair and happy relationships.
2 – The Curse of Compromise: This is so important because couples are often told that “marriage is all about compromise.” I strongly disagree.
Compromise always seems to have two features: (1) there is a winner and a loser. One partner gives in to the other partner’s request and (2) compromise usually only goes one-way. That is, one partner is more likely to do the asking, and expecting the other partner to make the compromise. If the compromising partner refuses, the asking partner gets angry.
image (image)The Five-Year Marriage recommends replacing compromise with negotiation. The basic framework is this: Consider what your partner is asking you to do. If it’s something you want, it’s an easy ‘yes’. If it isn’t something you want to do, but you know it’s important to your partner (like going to an event you don’t like) and you’re willing to do it for your partner, make it an exchange. That is, say “Yes, I would be OK doing [X] for you and, in exchange, will you do [X] for me?”
Am I Still Watching? As of this writing, I am. However, I’m past the MAFS addiction phase. And, since MAFS has its own channel, I can easily tune in for just one episode, or even just watch for a few minutes..
Do I think MAFS is worth watching? I do. Watching the couples work out their relationship is fascinating. Equally interesting is watching how the therapists make their decision to pair couples up and work with them through their eight weeks. And I’ve watched enough MAFS to have interesting conversations about it with Joseph (who actually watches with me sometimes). It’s not a football game, but he does find it curious, in a voyeur sort of way We watch together and laugh – maybe because it’s silly or maybe because we’ve had a certain argument or problem and do a “remember when that happened to us” conversation. And I also get a kick out shouting my own advice to them – as though they can hear me. 🙂
Let me know if you watch, and what you think. Tell me who your favorite couple is. Or was there a couple who annoyed you the most? What do you think of the end-of-season wrap-ups? Most importantly, please share one good good takeaway about relationships. You can post on my socials (FB or IG) or send me email at Annmarie@AnnmarieKelly.com
Something New is Coming!
As we’re making our way to the end of 2026, are you thinking your relationship could use some new energy in the new year? I’ve been working on a new program for 2027 – The Five-Year Marriage Reset. I’ll keep you posted with updates.
image
Wishing you and yours a wonderful Thanksgiving!
With love and in victory – and gratitude,
Annmarie
#ICYMI: My latest interview: The Wit or Witout Podcast?
imageDennis Slack is the host of the Wit or Witout podcast. He used to own a string of hoagie shops and has a history of making fabulous cheesesteaks (I take mine witout). A few years ago, a health issue forced him to change course. Dennis was always fascinated by people’s stories, and he loves Philly. So he started doing a podcast telling the stories of local Philly celebrities.
Last fall, Dennis called and asked me to do his podcast. I’m so glad I did. Dennis really researches his guests. When I did the interview, Dennis knew stories about me that I forgot I ever shared. He does that with all his guests, and he’s good at it – really lets his guests open up and be themselves. You can find all the Wit or Witout podcasts on Apple, Spotify, and wherever you get your podcasts.
Here’s my interview with Dennis: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/wit-or-wit-out-episode-14-annmarie-kelly/id1889643720?i=1000776121849.Let me know what you think…
Speaking of podcasts…
As I mentioned in my last newsletter, Joseph and I decided we are ready to start podcasting about The Five-Year Marriage. We’ve been meeting on and off for a year, and we’ll start soon. If you have some topics you would like Joseph and I to talk about, email me at Annmarie@AnnmarieKelly.com and put “new podcast” in the subject. I appreciate it.